Send us an email...

We're here to satisfy your every baseball humor desire, but if our posts just don't cover it, or if you have other questions or suggestions, just SEND US AN EMAIL:

Turk



Cuc



Thursday, June 3, 2010

Bad Umpiring

Ok I feel the need to vent about this. This all started back in the 2009 postseason (which is close enough to this season), oddly enough, the most notorious games all involved the Yankees. The Joe Mauer double that was called foul in game 2 of the ALDS, bothcalls against the Rockies involing Chase Utley in game 3 of the NLDS, Nick Swisher leaving early and the should-be double play at third with Posada and Cano in game 4 of the ALCS, and the blown calls in game 2 of the World Series. After all this hooplah, Bud Selig doesn't change a thing in the replay system.

And in the 2010 season, as a Rays fan, most of my bad umpiring experiences involve them, so bear with me. I'm sure there have been bad calls all across the league with every other team, but first, we're going to focus on Bob Davidson's crummy strike zone in a Rays-Red Sox matchup. This all culminated in a ball 10 inches off the plate being called a strike and CC and Joe Maddon raging all over Bob Davidson. Incident #2, last night in Toronto, on the Sean Rodriguez run. He clearly touched third base as he rounded it, but for whatever reason the run was called back, leaving the score at 2-1. Had that score held up, there would have been mass hysteria postgame.

And finally, this may end up being one of the most infamous calls in baseball history: the Jim Joyce call in Detroit that cost Armando Galarraga his perfect game. Yes, it was a close play in real time, but still a fairly clear out, and when you watch the replay, it's not even close. Galarraga beat Jason Donald by a full step and just like that, baseball history is lost and this goes into the books as many of the one-hitters in major league history. It's a shame. But I tip my cap to Jim Joyce, he took his mistake like a man and I can respect that, and even more, in a class move, in today's Tigers' game, Galarraga presented the lineup card to home plate umpire, Jim Joyce, showing no signs of bitterness. Gotta love that.

While yes human error is a part of major league baseball and part of the beauty of the game, the sooner we go to some instant replay system (like the NFL Challenge system) the better off we'll all be.

No comments:

Post a Comment